Skip to Main Content

English 110 - Handley: Thinking Critically About Health Info

This guide provides students with tips and suggested resources for research in English 110 with Elizabeth Handley

Health Information from the Internet (& the Library)

Do a quick Google search on a health-related topic and you will probably find millions or even billions of websites. But how can you find the best websites and how can you tell whether the information you're finding is reliable?

To find and identify the best online health information, you will need to do the following things:

  • Understand the different types of sources that share consumer health information and why they share it
  • Search strategically to generate search results that are more likely to include relevant, reliable information
  • Select strategically to choose the sources from your search results that are most likely to be reliable
  • Critically evaluate each source you choose to determine its level of reliability

Types of Sources of Health Information on the Internet

The internet is full of consumer health information written for a general audience.  This information comes from different types of sources and is shared for different purposes

Below is a list of some of the types of websites where you might find health information, using examples on the topic of raw milk.

 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Generated Content

Google search results often begin with an AI Overview of the topic, based on your search terms. Keep in mind that this content may not be accurate. Generative AI technology works by recognizing patterns it its source material (such as websites, articles, etc.) and mimicking those patterns to produce text that sounds like it was created by a human. The text generated by AI reflects the biases and inaccuracies of the source material and may also include content completely made up by the AI technology known as "hallucinations." 

 News media

News websites may report on health-related research studies, events, legislation, etc. 

Example: PBS News Raw milk sales spike despite CDC's warnings of risk associated with bird flu

 Government websites

Government websites may include public health information, searchable databases of publicly-funded research, tutorials for thinking critically about health information, and more.

Example: U.S. Food & Drug Administration Raw Milk

 Medical practices

Hospitals, clinics, and other medical practice websites may share health information and research, and may also promote their own services or products.

Example: Mayo Clinic Infectious Diseases A-Z: Raw milk, cheese linked to brucellosis

 Commercial consumer health websites

Commercial consumer health websites may include information on a range of health-related topics, similar to the kind of information you may find on government websites and medical practice websites. Commercial consumer health websites may also include ads and links to related products. 

Example: WebMD Raw Milk: Are There Health Benefits?

 Academic publishers

Publishers may provide information about research articles on health topics published in their scholarly journals. In many cases, including the example below, the full text of the article is not included. Ask a librarian for help finding the full text of any incomplete source you find online.

Example: ScienceDirect Hazards of a ‘healthy’ trend? An appraisal of the risks of raw milk consumption and the potential of novel treatment technologies to serve as alternatives to pasteurization

 Educational institutions

Colleges and university websites may include information about health-related research centers and programs, and news stories or press releases about their research. University repositories may include the full text of scholarly research articles and other publications written by their faculty.

Example: Stanford Medicine Nutrition Studies Research Group Effects of Raw Milk vs. Pasteurized Milk on Lactose Maldigestion and Symptoms of Lactose Intolerance Among Lactose Intolerance Adults

 Advocacy groups

Advocacy groups' websites may have articles, blog posts, videos, or other content promoting a particular point of view or fighting for specific legislation or other action on a health-related topic. 

Example: Raw Milk Institute Two Types of Raw Milk

 Retail companies

Retail company websites may include blogs or other pages, presented as news or scientific information on health topics, that are designed to market the products they sell.

Example: Vintage Meadows Raw Milk and Why it is so Important

 Individuals

Individuals may share their personal experiences on health-related topics through websites, blogs, videos, or social media. They may also advocate for particular points of view or legislation, and/or promote products.

Example: Cade Prior I Drank RAW Milk Everyday for 1 Year | Here's What Happened

While many of the above source types look similar at first glance, some are more likely to be biased an to share incomplete or inaccurate information, such as advocacy groups those selling products related to the topic. Other types of sources are more likely to provide accurate information backed up by evidence, such as scholarly research studies. You can increase your chances of finding credible sources by searching strategically and evaluating each source carefully, no matter what type of source it is.

Searching Strategically for Health Information

The following search strategies are designed for Google, but will work in many other internet search engines as well.

Use keywords instead of full sentences

Google allows natural language searching (using full sentences such as “what are the possible health benefits and potential dangers of drinking raw milk?”). But using full sentences might eliminate results that are actually relevant to your topic. Instead focus on the most important keywords, such as: raw milk health

Avoid terms that are biased or likely to get results from only one perspective

 Avoid: raw milk better; raw milk benefits

Try this: search box with the words raw milk health

Include search terms that are more likely to find scientific research

Terms related to scientific research include:

      • Evidence
      • Research study
      • Research review
      • Empirical evidence

Try this: search box with the words raw milk health research empirical evidence

Use scientific terms as well as common ones

If you don’t know the scientific term, look it up in Wikipedia

For example: try the term unpasteurized milk as well as raw milk

Limit your results to specific websites or domains

To find results only from educational institutions’ websites, add this to your Google search: site:.edu

For example: search box with the words raw milk site:.edu

Tip: You might find student work on educational websites. Be sure to evaluate the expertise of the authors and the credibility of the information you find, even on .edu sites.

To find results only from U.S. government websites, add this to your Google search: site:.gov

For example: search box with the words raw milk site:.gov

To find articles from The New York Times, add this to your Google search: site:nytimes.com

For example: search box with the words raw milk site:nytimes.com

Tip: The Luria Library provides free access to The New York Times website to SBCC students. Set up your access by following the instructions on the Newspapers @ Luria Library guide.

Limit your results to more current information

To find sources that were published more recently, select “Tools” at the top of your Google search results, then click on "Any time" to expand the menu and choose “Past year” or set a “Custom range” 

screenshot demonstrating how to limit Google search results by time

Use resources and search tools designed to find scholarly information

Recommended Resources for Finding Health Information Through Websites and Search Engines

      • MedlinePlus is “an online health information resource for patients and their families and friends.”
      • PubMed includes “more than 37 million citations for biomedical literature from MEDLINE, life science journals, and online books. Citations may include links to full text content from PubMed Central and publisher web sites.” If you can’t find the full text of a source, try searching for it in the Library’s OneSearch, or ask a librarian for help.
      • Google Scholar links to “articles, theses, books, abstracts and court opinions, from academic publishers, professional societies, online repositories, universities and other web sites.” If you can’t find the full text of a source, try searching for it in the Library’s OneSearch, or ask a librarian for help

Recommended Resources for Finding Health Information Through the Luria Library

The Luria Library’s collections provide free access to books, scholarly journal articles, and other sources related to health and medicine that you might not be able to find for free on the open internet.

      • OneSearch allows you to search most of the Library's resources at once. To limit your results to scholarly sources select "Peer-reviewed Journals" under "Availability" in the Filters.
      • The Luria Library's list of Bio-medical sciences databases include databases aimed at consumers, such as Health Source - Consumer Edition, and databases aimed at students, scholars, and healthcare professionals, such as CINAHL Plus with Full Text. Searching one database at a time allows you to limit your search results to the types of sources available in that database.

Selecting Sources Strategically from Your Search Results

Consider the types of health information sources you might find as you review your search results. Watch the following video for guidance on how to avoid ads and other less credible sources, and choose sources that are likely to be less biased and more reliable.

Critically Evaluating the Health Information You Find

Online consumer health information can be very useful, but might also be incomplete and oversimplified. It might be shared by people or organizations with conflicts of interest, such as those whose goal is to sell products.

In order to determine the validity of the information you find online, you need to answer three questions:

  • Who created the information and why?
  • What is the evidence for their claims and how strong is it?
  • What do other sources say about the creators/sharers of the information and the information itself?

To answer these questions, you will need to practice lateral reading rather than just looking at the website where you found the information. Watch the video below from University of Louisville Libraries to learn how to practice lateral reading.

See SIFT & PICK Fact Checking & Source Evaluation for more guidance on lateral reading and other source evaluation strategies.

More Resources for Thinking Critically About Health Information